The Hidden Benefits of Network Attack
An anonymous note in the Harvard Law Review argues that there is a significant benefit from Internet attacks:
This Note argues that computer networks, particularly the Internet, can be thought of as having immune systems that are strengthened by certain attacks. Exploitation of security holes prompts users and vendors to close those holes, vendors to emphasize security in system development, and users to adopt improved security practices. This constant strengthening of security reduces the likelihood of a catastrophic attack—one that would threaten national or even global security. In essence, certain cybercrime can create more benefits than costs, and cybercrime policy should take this concept into account.
jamgill • September 26, 2006 6:58 AM
So… being occasionally reminded of the systems’ weaknesses actually strengthens the overall system? Hmm… that works up to a point, but I belive that the depth of the underlying weaknesses, the ease with which they can be accessed, and the breadth to which they are distributed bears very badly for the overall functioning of the system. Just a single catastrophic failure in Windows, Cisco IOS, or Junos (for three handy examples) could cause a lot of heartburn on any given day. A pair of the problems that happened simultaneously … well, that would go a long way toward reminding everyone exactly how tenuous the systems we rely on every day really are.