Julian Sanchez on Balancing Privacy and Security
From a blog post:
In my own area of study, the familiar trope of “balancing privacy and security” is a source of constant frustration to privacy advocates, because while there are clearly sometimes tradeoffs between the two, it often seems that the zero-sum rhetoric of “balancing” leads people to view them as always in conflict. This is, I suspect, the source of much of the psychological appeal of “security theater”: If we implicitly think of privacy and security as balanced on a scale, a loss of privacy is ipso facto a gain in security. It sounds silly when stated explicitly, but the power of frames is precisely that they shape our thinking without being stated explicitly.
I’ve written about the false trade-off between security and privacy.
Rob K • February 11, 2011 1:24 PM
Privacy IS security. Any violation of privacy is a violation of security by definition.