The FBI is Tracking Whom?
They're tracking a college student in Silicon Valley. He's 20, partially Egyptian, and studying marketing at Mission College. He found the tracking device attached to his car. Near as he could tell, what he did to warrant the FBI's attention is be the friend of someone who did something to warrant the FBI's attention.
Afifi retrieved the device from his apartment and handed it over, at which point the agents asked a series of questions Â did he know anyone who traveled to Yemen or was affiliated with overseas training? One of the agents produced a printout of a blog post that Afifiâs friend Khaled allegedly wrote a couple of months ago. It had "something to do with a mall or a bomb," Afifi said. He hadnât seen it before and doesnât know the details of what it said. He found it hard to believe Khaled meant anything threatening by the post.
Here's the Reddit post:
bombing a mall seems so easy to do. i mean all you really need is a bomb, a regular outfit so you arent the crazy guy in a trench coat trying to blow up a mall and a shopping bag. i mean if terrorism were actually a legitimate threat, think about how many fucking malls would have blown up already.. you can put a bag in a million different places, there would be no way to foresee the next target, and really no way to prevent it unless CTU gets some intel at the last minute in which case every city but LA is fucked...so...yea...now i'm surely bugged : /
This weird story poses three sets of questions.
- Is the FBI's car surveillance technology that lame? Don't they have bugs that are a bit smaller and less obtrusive? Or are they surveilling so many people that they're forced to use the older models as well as the newer, smaller, stuff?
From a former FBI agent:
The former agent, who asked not to be named, said the device was an older model of tracking equipment that had long ago been replaced by devices that donât require batteries. Batteries die and need to be replaced if surveillance is ongoing so newer devices are placed in the engine compartment and hardwired to the carâs battery so they donât run out of juice. He was surprised this one was so easily found.
âIt has to be able to be removed but also stay in place and not be seen,â he said. âThereâs always the possibility that the car will end up at a body shop or auto mechanic, so it has to be hidden well. Itâs very rare when the guys find them."
- If they're doing this to someone so tangentially connected to a vaguely bothersome post on an obscure blog, just how many of us have tracking devices on our cars right now -- perhaps because of this blog? Really, is that blog post plus this enough to warrant surveillance?
Afifiâs father, Aladdin Afifi, was a U.S. citizen and former president of the Muslim Community Association here, before his family moved to Egypt in 2003. Yasir Afifi returned to the United States alone in 2008, while his father and brothers stayed in Egypt, to further his education he said. He knows heâs on a federal watchlist and is regularly taken aside at airports for secondary screening.
- How many people are being paid to read obscure blogs, looking for more college students to surveil?
Remember, the Ninth Circuit Court recently ruled that the police do not need a warrant to attach one of these things to your car. That ruling holds true only for the Ninth Circuit right now; the Supreme Court will probably rule on this soon.
Meanwhile, the ACLU is getting involved:
Brian Alseth from the American Civil Liberties Union in Washington state contacted Afifi after seeing pictures of the tracking device posted online and told him the ACLU had been waiting for a case like this to challenge the ruling.
âThis is the kind of thing we like to throw lawyers at,â Afifi said Alseth told him.
âIt seems very frightening that the FBI have placed a surveillance-tracking device on the car of a 20-year-old American citizen who has done nothing more than being half-Egyptian,â Alseth told Wired.com.
Posted on October 13, 2010 at 6:20 AM • 105 Comments