Verizon Monitoring Customers for Disney
This seems like a really bad idea.
Stepping up the battle against entertainment piracy, Verizon Communications Co. have entered a long-term programming deal that calls for the phone company to send a warning to Internet users suspected of pirating Disney’s content on its broadband services.
Under the deal, one of the first of its kind in the television industry, Disney will contact Verizon when the company suspects a Verizon customer of illegally downloading content. Without divulging names or addresses to Disney, Verizon will then alert the customer that he or she might be violating the law. Disney will be able to identify suspicious customers through an Internet coding system.
EDITED TO ADD: If you can’t read the Wall Street Journal link, another article.
Better-than-Nothing • September 23, 2005 7:56 AM
Reading the full article requires a susbscription I don’t have, so I didn’t read it. That said, from what is posted here, I don’t see any problem, in fact it’s a great idea.
Let’s face it, Disney can only identify IP addresses of downloaders. So short of suing some John Doe and issuing a civil subpoena, what can they do? Partnering with the ISP allows them to give notice to suspected pirates easily.
Once put on notice, Verizon customers will either 1.) cut it out, 2.) have a talk with their teenage kid(s) to about cutting it out, 3.) determine their computer is an open proxy through which all manner of Internet miscreants funnel traffic, or 4.) start using a proxy when pirating so somebody else gets the next “knock it off” notice.
What’s wrong with that? Most parents have no idea what their kids are doing online. Perhaps this would alert them. Same for compromised proxies computers.
Which leaves the people who are actually downloaded content illegally. What’s the harm in giving them fair warning? At least then, when they are sued or arrested, they won’t have the pathetic “I had no idea” excuse…