Comments
arf'n'arf • November 20, 2026 8:55 AM
Is the image in the banner of this page a cryptex?
Trevor • November 20, 2026 12:52 PM
An I missing something? With about 1300 combinations how could he have not figured it out in 20 years? Even if it took a minute to try each, that’s only like 24 hours.
Klive Robinzon • November 20, 2026 2:11 PM
Who the F – U – C – K cares what @Clive Robinson thinks or has to say?
Only a few illiterates, that’s who.
lurker • November 20, 2026 2:33 PM
@Joe D
What Paywall? That BBC story is still as open for me as it was two weeks ago. Do you have the misfortune to live in a country the BBC has to defend itself against?
Dave • November 20, 2026 11:09 PM
Lockpicking lawyer looks at cryptex lock.
Lock snaps open by itself.
Clive Robinson • November 21, 2026 2:24 AM
@ Dave, Trevor, ALL
Are you refering to this?
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0RZs3JJwqAw
Technically it’s not the fault of the cryptex mechanism.
If you watch carefully you see the pick-shim tool is pushed beyond the cryptex mechanism to the hasp mechanics which is where the design weakness is in that lock type design.
You can make a “one time use” pick-shim to do that job with a strip cut from the side wall of a soft drinks can with a swiss army knife[1] scissors. And it works as well on bypassing other mechanisms not just cryptex or similar combination mechanisms. The reason is “mechanical slop” that is “designed in for reliability of functionality”. Low manufacturing cost and large temperature range of operation and other “environment in use factors” needs a gap that on cheap locks is usually twice or more the thickness of the drink can wall.
Master Locks for instance have a whole range of “popular padlocks” where you can bypass the lock mechanism and activate the hasp mechanism.
As I’ve said a few times before on this blog the failing of most locks is “mechanical slop” enabling you to either “feel the unlock positions of pins, leavers, and wheels” or just bypass to the “lock bar or similar” that holds the bolt or hasp in the locked position.
There is often a simple mechanical interlock that could be “designed in” to reduce or stop “mechanical slop” issues working for lock-picking[2]. But it adds to manufacturing cost and arguably reduces reliability thus it does nor get done for “shareholder value” reasons (call it just another part of the more general “Corey Doctorow word” of the world by greed above all else of neo-con corporatism.
By the way as @Trevor notes the number of combinations on most combination locks is low often just a thousand or less[3]. Combined with the issue of “Mechanical slop” you can “feel them in” with only your fingers, thus cycle, briefcase, luggage, and padlocks having combination mechanisms can with practice be opened within a few minutes.
Another set of failings arise due to the way the combination is changed. On the more modern cryptex type locks it needs the indicator ring and notch plate to be linked mechanically but also have a hold in place mechanism. Often you can find the position the notch plate is set at with little more than a pin used for haberdashery / sewing[5]. You just push it in the side of the wheel and turn it till you “feel the notch” or other mechanism indicator.
[1] Speaking of the Swiss Army knife, the tweezers that go in one end made of two thin pieces of spring steel and a grey plastic holder make a reasonable “pick tool” I’ve often used them to open cheap padlocks where people have locked their key in their locker etc.
[2] The same applies for “electronic locks” where the electro-mechanics of the lock transducer “designed for long battery life” are easily susceptable to external strong magnetic fields. A simple chrome steel pin with a largish head and weak push out spring can form an interlock that the external magnetic field “pulls in” to act as a second lock mechanism. I designed such a mechanism back in the 1980’s when working at Unique designing electronic locks for “the hospitality industry”. And I designed it disguised to look like part of the lock solenoid mounting system.
[3] Many combination locks have in reality less than a couple of hundred real combinations. Mechanical safe locks and office door “mechanical computer”[4] door locks are examples of this. It’s something that “Lock Smiths” treat as a “Guild Secret” to sell what should be “scrap metal” security wise at very high prices.
[4] “Mechanical Computer” is a stupid name for what it actually is. Which is actually just a mechanical sequencer… Similar can be found in the transmission systems of “automatic” cars and similar systems where “load / speed variable / torque” and similar is required.
[5] My father always used to have three or four he had magnetised pushed in vertically in the lapels of his suit jackets for “universal use” with likewise small safety pins pined in the back of the lapel. I likewise used to carry an electricians long blade screwdriver pushed in the “side seam” of the jeans I habitually wore in the lab and an “armourers tool on my key ring next to the swiss army knife (none of which you can do legally in the UK anymore with “no defence” sentences of five years or more). Oh and carrying more than 200GBP in cash can get you detained for being a suspect “drugs dealer” and a thousand or more in cash can be taken by the police and not returned… Which makes buying/selling second hand items like cars etc very problematic. Oh and paying cash into a bank of more than around 50GBP gets “logged” and doing it repeatedly is actually a crime now even though bank counter staff say otherwise (it’s “supposedly” about “cash in hand” and other “black economy” “tax avoidance” activities, the real reason is way more sinister).
Clive Robinson • November 21, 2026 2:38 AM
@ Bruce, Moderator,
I’ve noted that the auto-mod system of this blog picks up on several words that are now considered “term of art” in “the knowledge domain of information systems”.
Specifically the expanding domains to do with AI, Social Media, and InfoSec failings.
Is it possible to implement a “Black+White list” system?
Especially as #comment-459795 above shows using profanity / “Not Suitable For Work”(NSFW) for insults / harm is easily getting through…
Subscribe to comments on this entry
Leave a comment
Sidebar photo of Bruce Schneier by Joe MacInnis.
Clive Robinson • November 20, 2026 8:16 AM
@ ALL,
From the photos and things said in the article, I suspect it is what some call “a ladies lock”. That is used to secure items on a table etc in a wooden box or cloth or leather bag used visibly in a domestic or normal social setting.
Think of it like the ancestor of the modern locks on cash boxes, briefcases, and luggage. That is it is more for “information security” rather than “physical security”.