Location Tracking App for Foreigners in Moscow

Russia is proposing a rule that all foreigners in Moscow install a tracking app on their phones.

Using a mobile application that all foreigners will have to install on their smartphones, the Russian state will receive the following information:

  • Residence location
  • Fingerprint
  • Face photograph
  • Real-time geo-location monitoring

This isn’t the first time we’ve seen this. Qatar did it in 2022 around the World Cup:

“After accepting the terms of these apps, moderators will have complete control of users’ devices,” he continued. “All personal content, the ability to edit it, share it, extract it as well as data from other apps on your device is in their hands. Moderators will even have the power to unlock users’ devices remotely.”

Posted on May 28, 2025 at 7:09 AM14 Comments

Comments

Dan H. May 28, 2025 7:54 AM

I suppose it is worth pointing out that whenever a government tries to gain information in a way that is transparently obvious, it generally results in that attempt being gamed?

An example was a cafe in London in the 1970s. The cafe was known for being a meeting-place of various political dissidents of all stripes and for that reason the police had seen fit to install a fairly obvious tap on the telephone.

As a result of realising this the cafe owner had decided upon a cunning plan to foil this tapping. Anyone leaving the cafe would be given a coin, perhaps 10 pence, and told to phone back and ask where the riot would be. On being told when and where, they should on no account even leave their house on that day.

This went on for some weeks with the police becoming more and more convinced that a huge political riot was due. Phrases such as “…and remember to bring your Sten gun” and “…don’t forget the petrol” helped the police along with this belief.

On the day of the riot the proposed site, a small park, was surrounded by huge numbers of police. The only civilian present was an elderly and exceedingly puzzled pensioner slowly walking an equally decrepit dog, which occasionally wagged its tail at police officers and showed no other interest in proceedings. After the pensioner had gone home the police were left completely alone to ponder the source of their intelligence.

The wire tap was removed soon afterwards.

Matej May 28, 2025 8:16 AM

What about Palestine? Israel was also intercepting and controlling everything.

Clive Robinson May 28, 2025 10:22 AM

@ Bruce, ALL,

The bullet point list you’ve quoted as to what Russia can do is as far as we know woefully incomplete.

The intent is almost certainly as bad if not worse than the quote about the Qatar “World Cup” App.

Also people need to remember that both Apple and Google built in a tracking / contact capability via “beaconing” for Covid and the “base of the system” is still present (as is similar for “client side scanning”).

The only safe thing to do would be to buy the cheapest and nastiest phone at the departure airport, don’t even bother putting a SIM in and dump the phone shortly before you come home or at the return airport.

Oh and leave it “on charge” “SIM out” in your hotel room as much as possible in a locked briefcase or bag you can easily make “tamper evident” to limit those “Evil Maids” who might decide theft is the best thing to do.

TimH May 28, 2025 10:44 AM

A subtlety from Clive’s comment is that what the Russian State is expecting to get from the app is probably similar from what USA can get right now through their relationships with Apple and Google.

lurker May 28, 2025 1:42 PM

@TimH

Another subtlety from @Clive’s comment would be the reason why my pre-Covid phone is not white-listed for 4G/VoLTE when our much delayed 3G shutdown happens later this year. The maker’s specs, and the online handbook clearly show the device is capable, but this is a Five Eyes nation and the local telco seems to have removed the function in an OTA “Security” update.

The Guy May 28, 2025 1:47 PM

I’d suggest just making everyone wear tracking anklets like violent criminals let out of prison on parole do… but I guess such a thing is very old fashioned. Phones give out much much more detailed and invasive information, and everyone has mostly accepted broadcasting all such information to everyone who wants it. Panopticon.

Winter May 28, 2025 2:08 PM

I suspect it is simply a tool of intimidation.

It is the old panopticon: All foreigners know they can be seen and heard at any time, but they are never sure when they are observed and when not.

The same holds for any Russian who speaks or contacts a foreigner. They know everything they say, write, or do can be observed. But they don’t know what is actually observed and stored.

It intimidates all foreigners and all Russians who come into contact with them. It extends the practice that is already working in telecommunication where Russians are afraid to tell family members outside Russia what they think over the phone.

I think that this intimidation is the only objective.

Stalin did the same using human spies, and the Poisoner is a great admirer of Stalin.

Robin May 28, 2025 2:31 PM

What happens if the visitor leaves the (albeit temporary) telephone in the hotel room? Oops, I forgot: I have a terrible memory.

Winter May 28, 2025 2:49 PM

@Robin

I forgot: I have a terrible memory.

They get arrested and thrown out of the country. Or they disappear. Whatever is convenient at the time.

This is a country where a lawyer in court has the same function as flowers at a funeral.[1]

[1] Quite from a Russian lawyer that defended political and human rights activists.

Bauke Jan Douma May 29, 2025 6:29 PM

@Winter

The origin of that Quite [sic] is an Israeli lawyer that defended political and human rights activists.

Activists, humans, their rights and the lawyer were all obliterated.

Who? (the real one) May 30, 2025 9:31 AM

Comment #445621 was not written by me, it is another “Who?”; not a problem, just want to make it clear it is not from me.

Foreigners attempting to avoid their obligation in relation to the new law will be added to a registry of monitored individuals and deported from Russia.

We are currently members of too many registries of monitored individuals in both our country and foreign ones. I guess the part about being deported is the one that is new, but I guess it will not be a huge problem for a short one-time trip to the other “land of liberty” (both are comparable, on general terms, even if historically are considered so different).

Leave a comment

Blog moderation policy

Login

Allowed HTML <a href="URL"> • <em> <cite> <i> • <strong> <b> • <sub> <sup> • <ul> <ol> <li> • <blockquote> <pre> Markdown Extra syntax via https://michelf.ca/projects/php-markdown/extra/

Sidebar photo of Bruce Schneier by Joe MacInnis.