AT&T Does Not Care about Your Privacy
AT&T’s CEO believes that the company should not offer robust security to its customers:
But tech company leaders aren’t all joining the fight against the deliberate weakening of encryption. AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson said this week that AT&T, Apple, and other tech companies shouldn’t have any say in the debate.
“I don’t think it is Silicon Valley’s decision to make about whether encryption is the right thing to do,” Stephenson said in an interview with The Wall Street Journal. “I understand [Apple CEO] Tim Cook’s decision, but I don’t think it’s his decision to make.”
His position is extreme in its disregard for the privacy of his customers. If he doesn’t believe that companies should have any say in what levels of privacy they offer their customers, you can be sure that AT&T won’t offer any robust privacy or security to you.
Does he have any clue what an anti-market position this is? He says that it is not the business of Silicon Valley companies to offer product features that might annoy the government. The “debate” about what features commercial products should have should happen elsewhere—presumably within the government. I thought we all agreed that state-controlled economies just don’t work.
My guess is that he doesn’t realize what an extreme position he’s taking by saying that product design isn’t the decision of companies to make. My guess is that AT&T is so deep in bed with the NSA and FBI that he’s just saying things he believes justify his position.
Here’s the original, behind a paywall.
Daniel • February 10, 2016 2:07 PM
I agree with the CEO that ultimately it isn’t the tech companies decision. They live in a democracy and are bound by the same rules as everyone else. At the same time, tech companies have an obligation to lead by example which is what Apple is doing. To suggest otherwise is to imply that the debate is over, which it is not. Moreover, I’d argue that tech companies have a special obligation in this regard because they have the most technical expertise.
SO I think he’s right to say that ultimately it is not up to Silicon Valley. I think he is wrong to imply that Silicon Valley doesn’t have an important role to play.